de LUCY / MARMION / CAUNTELO

Moderator: MOD_nyhetsgrupper

Svar
rainbow.

de LUCY / MARMION / CAUNTELO

Legg inn av rainbow. » 06 des 2007 18:58:19

Does this help clarify the de LUCY / MARMION / CAUNTELO
puzzle?

http://www.geneajourney.com/marmion.html

wjhonson

Re: de LUCY / MARMION / CAUNTELO

Legg inn av wjhonson » 07 des 2007 05:55:03

On Dec 6, 9:58 am, "rainbow." <"rainbow."@clear.net.nz> wrote:
Does this help clarify the de LUCY / MARMION / CAUNTELO
puzzle?

http://www.geneajourney.com/marmion.html

---------
Except they have not been keeping up here.
Robert Marmion the son of Robert Marion and Millicent of Rethel,
married a woman named Elizabeth whose parentage is not known. *Their*
son, also Robert "feudal lord of Tamworth" is the one who married Maud
de Beauchamp firstly, and secondly a woman named Philip of unknown
parentage.

Will Johnson

JohnR

Re: de LUCY / MARMION / CAUNTELO

Legg inn av JohnR » 07 des 2007 14:40:03

On Dec 7, 4:54 am, wjhonson <wjhon...@aol.com> wrote:
On Dec 6, 9:58 am, "rainbow." <"rainbow."@clear.net.nz> wrote:

Does this help clarify the de LUCY / MARMION / CAUNTELO
puzzle?

http://www.geneajourney.com/marmion.html

---------
Except they have not been keeping up here.
Robert Marmion the son of Robert Marion and Millicent of Rethel,
married a woman named Elizabeth whose parentage is not known. *Their*
son, also Robert "feudal lord of Tamworth" is the one who married Maud
de Beauchamp firstly, and secondly a woman named Philip of unknown
parentage.

Will Johnson

Are you saying that there is a new generation called Robert between
Robert Marmion and wife Millicent and Robert who married (1) Phillipa
-- and (2) Maud de Beauchamp?
Time-wise this looks possible however it would upset the supposition
that it was Robert husband of de Beauchamp (rather than a Roger
husband of Elizabeth) who received Coventry from Ranulf, Earl of
Chester ca. 1146. If the extra generation does exist then it might
possibly add weight to the argument that Ranulf's charter was a
forgery.

What is your source for Bobby and Liz?

John

Svar

Gå tilbake til «soc.genealogy.medieval»