Presidential line discrepancy?

Moderator: MOD_nyhetsgrupper

Svar
Leo van de Pas

Presidential line discrepancy?

Legg inn av Leo van de Pas » 10 apr 2007 00:19:37

Gary Boyd Roberts in his Ancestors of American Presidents Page 284 gives

Jan Roos = Maria Vigne
Gerrit Roos (1) = Aeltje Lamberts
Johannes Roos = Cornelia
Cornelia Roos = Robert Benson
Trijntje Benson = Martin Hoffman
Cornelis Hoffman = Isaac Roosevelt

In the Dutch genealogical magazine "Gens Nostra" 2000 page 482

Pieter Janszoon Roos = Aaltje Lamberts Wolf

Pieter Roos (1) = 16 February 1676 Utrecht Elisabeth van 't Horsken, she was buried 5 June 1697 in Utrecht

Cornelia Roos baptised 3 May 1685 Jacobskerk, Utrecht (1) = 14 March 1708 New York Robert Benson
(2) = 25 August 1716 New York Anthony Rutgers

Trijntje (Catharina) Benson born 30 May 1712 Kingston, New York, died (?) 31 March 1765 Dutchess County New York,
she married 19 October 1733 New York County Martin Hoffman

Cornelia Hoffman born 13 August 1734 Kingston, New York died 13 November 1789 New York County
she married 1752 Dutchess County, New York, Isaac Roosevelt

-------------------------------
Gary Boyd Roberts has three generations before Cornelia Roos, the Dutch magazine only two but those two are different from what Gary Boyd Roberts gives. Is there anyone who can tell which is the correct one?

With many thanks
Leo van de Pas
Canberra, Australia

Gjest

Re: Presidential line discrepancy?

Legg inn av Gjest » 10 apr 2007 01:00:23

On Apr 9, 7:19 pm, "Leo van de Pas" <leovd...@netspeed.com.au> wrote:
Gary Boyd Roberts in his Ancestors of American Presidents Page 284 gives

Jan Roos = Maria Vigne
Gerrit Roos (1) = Aeltje Lamberts
Johannes Roos = Cornelia
Cornelia Roos = Robert Benson
Trijntje Benson = Martin Hoffman
Cornelis Hoffman = Isaac Roosevelt

In the Dutch genealogical magazine "Gens Nostra" 2000 page 482

Pieter Janszoon Roos = Aaltje Lamberts Wolf

Pieter Roos (1) = 16 February 1676 Utrecht Elisabeth van 't Horsken, she was buried 5 June 1697 in Utrecht

Cornelia Roos baptised 3 May 1685 Jacobskerk, Utrecht (1) = 14 March 1708 New York Robert Benson
(2) = 25 August 1716 New York Anthony Rutgers

Trijntje (Catharina) Benson born 30 May 1712 Kingston, New York, died (?) 31 March 1765 Dutchess County New York,
she married 19 October 1733 New York County Martin Hoffman

Cornelia Hoffman born 13 August 1734 Kingston, New York died 13 November 1789 New York County
she married 1752 Dutchess County, New York, Isaac Roosevelt

-------------------------------
Gary Boyd Roberts has three generations before Cornelia Roos, the Dutch magazine only two but those two are different from what Gary Boyd Roberts gives. Is there anyone who can tell which is the correct one?


The trick to using Gary's work is looking at the sources on p. 162 for
FDR. He's getting his information from the New York Genealogical and
Biographical Record (NYGBR) 90 (1959):164-5 (Roos), so you need to
compare that source with the one you've got. The discrepancy seems to
be in the Roos family.

Svar

Gå tilbake til «soc.genealogy.medieval»