John Carmi Parsons once stated that eleanor had nine children from her
marriage to Henry II. Who was this ninth child?
Rashid
eleanor of aquitaine
Moderator: MOD_nyhetsgrupper
-
D. Spencer Hines
Re: Eleanor Of Aquitaine
No.
Henry II and Eleanor reportedly had EIGHT CHILDREN -- NOT NINE.
The first, William, died at age TWO.
Where is your quotation and cite from John Parsons?
D. Spencer Hines
Lux et Veritas et Libertas
Vires et Honor
"Rashid Amora" <doosje@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:IMRLd.15156$o9.13435@amsnews03-serv.chello.com...
| John Carmi Parsons once stated that eleanor had nine children from her
| marriage to Henry II. Who was this ninth child?
| Rashid
Henry II and Eleanor reportedly had EIGHT CHILDREN -- NOT NINE.
The first, William, died at age TWO.
Where is your quotation and cite from John Parsons?
D. Spencer Hines
Lux et Veritas et Libertas
Vires et Honor
"Rashid Amora" <doosje@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:IMRLd.15156$o9.13435@amsnews03-serv.chello.com...
| John Carmi Parsons once stated that eleanor had nine children from her
| marriage to Henry II. Who was this ninth child?
| Rashid
-
Peter Stewart
Re: Eleanor Of Aquitaine
"D. Spencer Hines" <poguemidden@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:B7SLd.734$6k.9888@eagle.america.net...
Apparently they had nine, as John Carmis Parsons has said. Luckily I still
have brain function enough to check such things before posting about them.
There was evidently a son, whose name is not known, born either in 1160/1 or
1163/4, who died in infancy.
This was discussed by Andrew Lewis in 'The Birth and Childhood of King John:
Some Revisions', _Eleanor of Aquitaine: Lord and Lady_, edited by John Carmi
Parsons & Bonnie Wheeler (New York & Basingstoke, 2002) p. 161 and note 10.
Peter Stewart
news:B7SLd.734$6k.9888@eagle.america.net...
No.
Henry II and Eleanor reportedly had EIGHT CHILDREN -- NOT NINE.
The first, William, died at age TWO.
Apparently they had nine, as John Carmis Parsons has said. Luckily I still
have brain function enough to check such things before posting about them.
There was evidently a son, whose name is not known, born either in 1160/1 or
1163/4, who died in infancy.
This was discussed by Andrew Lewis in 'The Birth and Childhood of King John:
Some Revisions', _Eleanor of Aquitaine: Lord and Lady_, edited by John Carmi
Parsons & Bonnie Wheeler (New York & Basingstoke, 2002) p. 161 and note 10.
Peter Stewart
-
D. Spencer Hines
Re: Eleanor Of Aquitaine
Hilarious!
Pogue Stewart can't come up with a viable quotation and alleged proof
for same either.
Par for the course with Pogue Stewart The Brain-Damaged -- by his OWN
admission.
D. Spencer Hines
Lux et Veritas et Libertas
Vires et Honor
"Peter Stewart" <p_m_stewart@msn.com> wrote in message
news:YBSLd.144276$K7.13770@news-server.bigpond.net.au...
|
| "D. Spencer Hines" <poguemidden@hotmail.com> wrote in message
| news:B7SLd.734$6k.9888@eagle.america.net...
| > No.
| >
| > Henry II and Eleanor reportedly had EIGHT CHILDREN -- NOT NINE.
| >
| > The first, William, died at age TWO.
|
| Apparently they had nine, as John Carmis [sic] Parsons has said.
Luckily I still
| have brain function enough to check such things before posting about
them.
|
| There was evidently a son, whose name is not known, born either in
1160/1 or
| 1163/4, who died in infancy.
|
| This was discussed by Andrew Lewis in 'The Birth and Childhood of King
John:
| Some Revisions', _Eleanor of Aquitaine: Lord and Lady_, edited by John
Carmi
| Parsons & Bonnie Wheeler (New York & Basingstoke, 2002) p. 161 and
note 10.
|
| Peter Stewart
Pogue Stewart can't come up with a viable quotation and alleged proof
for same either.
Par for the course with Pogue Stewart The Brain-Damaged -- by his OWN
admission.
D. Spencer Hines
Lux et Veritas et Libertas
Vires et Honor
"Peter Stewart" <p_m_stewart@msn.com> wrote in message
news:YBSLd.144276$K7.13770@news-server.bigpond.net.au...
|
| "D. Spencer Hines" <poguemidden@hotmail.com> wrote in message
| news:B7SLd.734$6k.9888@eagle.america.net...
| > No.
| >
| > Henry II and Eleanor reportedly had EIGHT CHILDREN -- NOT NINE.
| >
| > The first, William, died at age TWO.
|
| Apparently they had nine, as John Carmis [sic] Parsons has said.
Luckily I still
| have brain function enough to check such things before posting about
them.
|
| There was evidently a son, whose name is not known, born either in
1160/1 or
| 1163/4, who died in infancy.
|
| This was discussed by Andrew Lewis in 'The Birth and Childhood of King
John:
| Some Revisions', _Eleanor of Aquitaine: Lord and Lady_, edited by John
Carmi
| Parsons & Bonnie Wheeler (New York & Basingstoke, 2002) p. 161 and
note 10.
|
| Peter Stewart
-
Peter Stewart
Re: Eleanor Of Aquitaine
"Dayne" Spencer Hines (who has at last broken out of his "D" cluster of
goofs into new mistake territory) wrote:
Quite obviously since I posted a reference for the discussion of this
by someone who has carefully researched the matter, it is not true to
say I "can't" come up with the evidence presented by Lewis. I am not
obliged to quote him or his source any more than did Spencer quote (or
even cite) a reference for his capitalised & erroneous assertion that
there were only eight children.
Par for the course here is the failure & indeed constant refusal by
Spencer Hines to admit his own shortcomings.
The only genealogical fact he has tried to put forward for some while
turned out to be a show of his own ignorance, and yet he tries to turn
the subject into further embarrassment for himself. I am not here to
provide a look-up service for Hawaiian unter-pogues.
Peter Stewart
goofs into new mistake territory) wrote:
Hilarious!
Pogue Stewart can't come up with a viable quotation and alleÂged
proof for same either.
Quite obviously since I posted a reference for the discussion of this
by someone who has carefully researched the matter, it is not true to
say I "can't" come up with the evidence presented by Lewis. I am not
obliged to quote him or his source any more than did Spencer quote (or
even cite) a reference for his capitalised & erroneous assertion that
there were only eight children.
Par for the course with Pogue Stewart The Brain-Damaged -- bÂy his
OWN admission.
Par for the course here is the failure & indeed constant refusal by
Spencer Hines to admit his own shortcomings.
The only genealogical fact he has tried to put forward for some while
turned out to be a show of his own ignorance, and yet he tries to turn
the subject into further embarrassment for himself. I am not here to
provide a look-up service for Hawaiian unter-pogues.
Peter Stewart
-
Stewart Baldwin
Re: eleanor of aquitaine
On Tue, 01 Feb 2005 20:38:00 GMT, "Rashid Amora" <doosje@hotmail.com>
wrote:
An unnamed son said to have died young.
See http://sbaldw.home.mindspring.com/hproj ... nry002.htm
Stewart Baldwin
wrote:
John Carmi Parsons once stated that eleanor had nine children from her
marriage to Henry II. Who was this ninth child?
An unnamed son said to have died young.
See http://sbaldw.home.mindspring.com/hproj ... nry002.htm
Stewart Baldwin